From Good Housekeeping to The New York Times, These 5 Comforters Have Serious Street Cred—But Which One Is The Best?

So, You’re in the Market for a Comforter…

You want to sleep like a baby, cocooned in warmth and luxury…but don’t know what the right pick is. Well, you’re in luck because we’ve done the legwork for you. We’ve rounded up the most hyped-up, talked-about comforters in the game and pitted them against each other to see which one comes out on top across four different categories: Comfort & Coziness, Durability, Sustainability, and Price & Value. 

The contenders? Buffy’s Breeze Comforter, Brooklinen’s Down Comforter, Cozy Earth’s Comforter, Riley Home’s White Goose Down Comforter, and Parachute’s Down Duvet Insert.

Now, without further ado, let’s get into it:

Comfort & Coziness: Buffy

First up, coziness. This is the “Can-I-Just-Stay-in-Bed-Forever?” category. We want a comforter that makes us feel like we’re floating on a cloud, and when it comes to comfort, Buffy’s Breeze Comforter takes the crown, delivering the perfect combination of fluffiness and breathability. It’s no wonder the Breeze Comforter is an Architectural Digest 2023 award-winner. 

As for the other competitors, Brooklinen’s Down Comforter and Riley Home’s White Goose Down Comforter bring the heat and the fluff, but might leave you waking up in a sweat through the warmer months. Cozy Earth and Parachute? Well, they based on customer reviews, they might leave you hanging in the cold a bit. Buffy’s bestselling option will keep you toasty without feeling like you’re in a sauna. Its premium cooling abilities are the name of the game for hot sleepers (or any type of sleeper).

Durability: Buffy

This is where you want a comforter to go the distance without shedding feathers like a molting chicken. Riley Home’s White Goose Down Comforter, Brooklinen’s Down Comforter, and Parachute’s Down Duvet Insert are likelier to have feathers popping out everywhere, which is unfortunately inevitable with down-filled comforters. On the other hand, Cozy Earth is naturally resistant to wear and tear, making it a top contender in this category. But in our experience, we found it had a light odor that didn’t go away when washed.

Our top pick for durability is Buffy’s Breeze Comforter, thanks to its high-quality construction, easy-care design, and eucalyptus-based fabric. Eucalyptus lyocell is highly durable, wrinkle-resistant, and becomes softer with use and every wash. Buffy even included wave-pattern stitching to ensure the fill stays in place through years of snuggles and sleeps. To keep it in top shape, they recommend dry-clean only.

Sustainability: Buffy

In the green corner, we’ve got some heavyweights, but Buffy’s Breeze Comforter boasts the sustainability champ title. Crafted from eucalyptus fibers, its fluff and shell are as soft on you as they are on the planet. Their commitment to sustainability is unmatched: Buffy’s signature TENCEL™ eucalyptus lyocell fiber fill is fully biodegradable and compostable, and contains no essential oils, making it safe for pets and kids.

Cozy Earth’s Comforter is a close second, with a bamboo-based shell. However, it’s filled with silk, which often demands significant energy for production and carries a substantial environmental footprint. Brooklinen’s Down Comforter, Riley Home’s White Goose Down Comforter, and Parachute’s Down Duvet Insert Comforter? Well, their (down)side is using animal-based fill. 

Price & Value: Buffy

Now, let’s talk dollars and cents. While all these comforters might give luxurious hugs, not all of them are wallet-friendly. When it comes to getting the most bang for your buck, Buffy’s Breeze Comforter takes the cake (yup, again). It comes in at a reasonable price without compromising on quality, sustainability, or durability. The Twin/Twin XL is available for as low as $175, the Full/Queen goes for $245, and the King/Cal King is $289.

Brooklinen’s Down Comforter, Riley Home’s White Goose Down Comforter, and Parachute’s Down Duvet All Season Insert are all on the pricier side. Brooklinen’s Full/Queen size has a $379 price tag, while Riley Home’s Comforter starts at $475 for a Full/Queen size, and Parachute’s Full size goes for $470. Finally, Cozy Earth’s Comforter… might make your wallet weep. Their Full/Queen size starts at a whopping $769.00.

The Winner Takes it All: Buffy’s Breeze Comforter

Buffy’s Breeze Comforter is the clear champion—giving you all the cozy feels without breaking the bank. The Breeze Comforter wins first place in every category for its unmatched quality and year-round convenience. It’s fluffy and cozy, temperature-regulating, eco-friendly, and extremely durable—which is, in our eyes, the best of all worlds.

But hey, don’t take our word for it. Thousands of customers can’t seem to get enough of Buffy’s Breeze Comforter. And now we know why! What’s more: Buffy offers a free sleep trial, where you get to experience Buffy for 7 nights before buying, risk-free—on top of a 50 night return policy. Oh, and did we mention U.S. shipping is free? 

If you’re looking for the crème de la crème of comforters, Buffy’s Breeze stands head and shoulders above the rest. Remember, when it comes to bedding, it’s not just about the threads; it’s about the dreams they weave.

Get that well-deserved beauty sleep with the Breeze Comforter and savor the ultimate in comfort, breathability, and bedtime bliss.