The Best Bedding Brands, According to Our Sleepiest Staffers

Home Goods

The Best Bedding Brands, According to Our Sleepiest Staffers

There’s a lot that comes into play when choosing the right bedding. We tested the best selling sheets from top brands and here’s what we found.

12/30/2022

If You Haven’t Updated Your Bed In a While, It May Be Time To Do So

When it comes to a good night’s sleep, even if you don’t need to buy a new mattress, a new bedding set can make the difference.

We’ve tested more than 500 bedding items over the past few years. Everything from the fabric’s strength and shrinkage after washing, to its softness and overall impact on sleep quality is taken into consideration. The quality of your sleep and the look of your bedroom can be greatly influenced by the bedding you choose. In order to find high-quality bedding that suits a wide range of preferences and sleeping styles, we’ve researched and tested for months. Here are the best places to buy your next set of sheets and blankets:

Best Overall Sheets: Brooklinen

Aside from their high ranking on our test, these sheets come with free shipping and returns (even if you’ve used them and don’t like them), so there’s no reason not to give them a shot. Their range of award-winning sheets includes five styles made of different materials to choose from. Several colors and limited-edition options are available in every sheet set. We decided to test he most popular option: the Classic Percale Sheets.

The smooth, strong, and pill-resistant 100% cotton fabric performed well in our tests. The fabric was also described as “soft” and “smooth” by our panel. They’re also easier to fit on a bed since the fitted sheets come with tabs labeled “long side” and “short side.”

What we like about it:

  • High-quality goods at reasonable prices
  • Patterns and colors for every aesthetic
  • Top-notch level of customer care
  • Return policy for 365 days
  • Sleep trial

What we don’t like about it:

  • Sheets may be too short for taller people

Best Breathable Sheets: L.L Bean

When it comes to bedding, L.L. Bean has a reasonably large selection of rustic and homey options, including its Ultrasoft Comfort Flannel Sheet Set. If you browse their bedding, you’ll see a lot of plaids, woodsy prints, and sherpa fabric, but don’t be fooled—most of their products are still made from high-quality materials, such as Egyptian cotton and premium goose down. In addition, the company provides a one-year return policy to ensure that you are completely satisfied with your new bedding.

Also, the 280-Thread-Count Pima Cotton Percale Sheet Set is made from high-quality cotton in a basic weave and is ideal for those who prefer cool, crisp sheets to silky ones. In addition, it’s less expensive than other high-quality cotton sets, and it comes in a wide variety of solid colors to choose from.

What we like about it:

  • Cool to the touch and breathable
  • Durable fabric with a crisp, yet soft feel
  • One-of-a-kind designs
  • There is a one-year return period

What we don’t like about it:

  • A smaller number of sheet style choices

Best For Hot Sleepers: Buffy

Buffy’s bedding is made from eco-friendly materials that keep you cool, making it the perfect option for hot sleepers. For those who also value sustainability, Buffy is not only good on you but also on the environment. Customers can choose The Breeze Sheet Set from the Eucalyptus Collection or the luxurious Linen Sheet Set. Buffy offers crowd-favorite comfort with its comforters, mattress protectors, blankets and pillows. Basically everything you’ll ever need to make your bed the comfiest it can be.

The Buffy Cloud Comforter is one of the brand’s most popular products and a big hit with our test groups. Medium-weight, magically cozy, cool-to-the-touch and machine-washable. Made with a TENCEL eucalyptus lyocell outer shell that helps absorb moisture, and filled with a sustainable synthetic fill made from recycled plastic bottles. The Cloud has won countless awards as the top comforter on the market today.

The Breeze Sheet Set is personally our top choice when it comes to bed linens. After using the sheets for a few weeks, our testers were pleased with how soft they were and how little wrinkling they experienced after washing. All Buffy products come with a free 7-day trial period. In other words, you can try one of their products and return it for free if you don’t like it. In order to receive a refund, all returns must be made within 30 days of purchase.

What we like about it:

  • Free trial for 7 days
  • Cooling eucalyptus material
  • Year-round use
  • Eco-friendly products

What we don’t like about it:

  • Color options are limited

Best for Minimalists: Parachute

Parachute specializes in more earthy styles—think lots of brown and green hues and cozy textures. One of its most popular products is the Linen Sheet Set, but the brand also carries a variety of percale, sateen, and brushed cotton sheets.

When you’re looking for a new mattress, you don’t have to settle for anything less than a Parachute Eco Comfort Mattress, which is made out of pocketed steel coils and pure wool rather than memory foam.

What we like about it:

  • Superior quality
  • Colors and patterns are both earthy and modern
  • Top sheets are optional
  • Physical stores can be found in a number of cities

What we don’t like about it:

  • Sheets come with no guarantee or trial period

The Bottom Line

Each set of sheets is put through its paces in our textiles lab and in the homes of real consumers who act as real-world beta testers. When we test in the lab, we look at things like fabric strength, pilling resistance, wrinkle resistance, shrinkage and appearance after washing, and more. Softness, comfort, and temperature regulation are among the many factors considered by sleep testers. When looking for the best bed sheets, don’t just focus on the thread count; also take into account the material and features to ensure your comfort.